Premium Quality Materials

Each topper is crafted for durability and presentation:

• Printed on heavyweight cardstock
• Laminated for shine and frosting protection
• High-resolution, vibrant photo printing
• Mounted on sturdy white cake pop sticks
• Approx. 3 inches tall

Designed to look flawless from party setup through the last slice of cake.

Personalization Options

Upload 2–3 clear, forward-facing photos during checkout.

You’ll receive a proof within 24 hours before production begins to ensure everything is perfect.

If two photos are favorites, we can split the design at no extra cost (12 or more only).

Available Quantities

Cupcake toppers sold in sets of 6, 12, 18, and 24 toppers. 

Perfect for cupcakes, smash cakes, dessert trays, and party favors.

Perfect For MVP Baseball Party Decorations & Custom Sports Favors

• Personalized Milestone Birthdays: Specifically designed to highlight ages 2 through 100 with a custom-printed cap.

• "All-Star" & "Home Run" Themes: Pairs perfectly with stadium snacks, red-pinstripe decor, and classic backyard ballgames.

• Custom Name & Age Parties: Ideal for parents who want more than just a generic theme and want to see "[Name] is [Age]" front and center.

• Sports-Themed School Celebrations: A hit for classroom treats when your little athlete wants to share their big day with the team.

• Rookie of the Year (1st Birthday): The most popular theme for little sluggers.

• "Two" Legit to Quit (2nd Birthday): A top-trending sports-themed search.

• All-Star Team Celebrations: Perfect for end-of-season team parties.

• Concession Stand Decor: Use these as picks for sliders, donuts, or fruit cups.

• Double Play Keepsakes: High-quality photo integration that parents love to save.

Handmade With Care

Every topper is designed and assembled by hand using professional materials. We focus on crisp printing, strong construction, and party-ready presentation so your decorations feel as special as the occasion.

Processing and Shipping Information

Please review your event date when ordering. Processing is 1-3 business days after proof approval. Shipping is standard 3-5 business days. Upgraded shipping options are available at checkout if you need your decorations sooner. Tracking is provided once your order ships.

Looking for Matching Decorations?

Coordinating baseball party items are available in our Baseball Rookie of the Year Collection as well as separate listings, including banners, cake toppers, Capri Sun drink labels, water bottle labels, gable favor boxes, and full party bundles.

Step up to the plate and hit a home run with your party planning! Our toppers are crafted for durability and vibrant color, ensuring they look great in every birthday photo. Choose your quantity, provide the age, and let’s get your All-Star celebration started!

Frequently Asked Questions

What size are the baseball cupcake toppers?

Each topper measures approximately 3 inches tall (depending on the photo shape) and is mounted on a sturdy white cake pop stick, making them the perfect size for standard cupcakes and smash cakes.

Can I choose my own baseball cap colors?

Yes! This Vintage Rookie All-Star design is available in classic red, white, and blue as well as green, blue, red, or brown/tan. Custom color requests may be available for an additional design fee.

How long does production take?

Production takes 1–3 business days after proof approval. A digital proof is sent within 24 hours of your order so you can review your personalized photo baseball toppers before printing.

What happens if I don’t approve the proof?

If no approval is received within 24 hours of the proof being sent, production will begin automatically to help prevent delays for your event date.

Where do the cupcake toppers ship from?

All orders ship from North Carolina.

How long does shipping take?

Standard shipping typically arrives within 3–5 business days. Expedited shipping options are available at checkout if you’re working with a tight baseball birthday timeline.

Are the cupcake toppers durable?

Yes! Each topper is professionally printed on heavyweight cardstock and laminated for shine and frosting protection. They are sturdy, photo-ready, and designed to hold up beautifully on dessert tables and smash cakes.